Pine Island sits west of Cape Coral, reached by a single road through the fishing village of Matlacha. It is one of the largest islands in Florida, but it doesn’t have Gulf beaches. Instead it is ringed by mangroves and surrounded by Pine Island Sound and Matlacha Pass, which makes it a favorite with boaters and anglers.
The island has a laid-back, old-Florida pace, with tropical fruit groves, nurseries, small marinas and local seafood spots.
Communities on Pine Island
Bokeelia is on the north end, with homes on the water and views toward Boca Grande. Pineland on the west side is small and quiet, known for its Calusa history. St. James City on the south end has a network of canals and many homes with docks. Matlacha is the colorful village you pass through on the way in.
What to check before you buy
- Boating route. Check water depth, bridge clearance and the route to open water for the boat you own or plan to buy.
- Flood zone and elevation. Much of the island is low. Get the elevation certificate and flood quotes early.
- Seawall and dock. Have them inspected separately from the house.
- Drive time. There is one road on and off the island, through Matlacha. Factor that into commutes and storm plans.
Life on Pine Island
The pace is slow and the setting is natural. Residents fish from their docks, run boats out to Cayo Costa and the barrier islands, paddle the mangrove trails and buy fruit from local farm stands. Matlacha’s galleries and waterfront restaurants are a short drive away.
There are a few small grocery stores and shops on the island, but most bigger errands mean a trip into Cape Coral, roughly 20 to 40 minutes depending on where you live.
Who buys on Pine Island
Buyers are often boaters and anglers, retirees who want peace and quiet, and people looking for land, groves or nurseries. Some own second homes they use in winter.
Selling a home on Pine Island
Water access sells homes here. Describe the boating route, water depth and bridge clearance in your listing, and have dock and seawall details ready. Buyers will also ask about elevation and storm history.
Pine Island real estate FAQ
Does Pine Island have beaches?
No. Pine Island is surrounded by mangroves rather than sandy beaches. Beaches on Sanibel, Captiva and Fort Myers Beach are a drive or a boat ride away.
How do you get to Pine Island?
From Cape Coral, take Pine Island Road west across the Matlacha bridge. It is the only road onto the island.
Which part of Pine Island is best for boaters?
Many boaters choose St. James City for its canals or Bokeelia for its access to Charlotte Harbor and Boca Grande. The best fit depends on your boat and where you like to go.
Comparing areas? See the Lee County guide or the Cape Coral guide.
